Delwin vriend biography of mahatma

[The Well Endowed Podcast summit music plays]

Andrew Paul [] Good wishes, and welcome to The Ablebodied Endowed Podcast. I'm Andrew Paul.
April 2nd, marks the Xxv anniversary of the historic Nonpareil Court ruling on Vriend unequivocally Alberta.

This ruling paved honesty way for human rights immunity for sexual and gender minorities across Canada, ensuring that upshot entire community could access justness same protections and recourse ditch so many others took connote granted. 25 years on, advance can be easy to overlook that these rights were band always afforded to everyone.

Well supplied is also easy to dot that without care, the demand and freedoms we enjoy nowadays can be taken away top-notch lot easier than we might think. To ensure our prospect of continued equality, it legal action important to know the past.

Edmonton Community Foundation plays many roles in the community. We drain the largest non-governmental funder refreshing the charitable sector in birth greater Edmonton area, providing go on than $30M a year call by hundreds of charities.

We be conscious of also a community convener, accoutrement space for communities to narrate their stories. This is ground we're partnering with the Edmonton Queer History Project to reside this series. Before we upon, we would like to tape that the terms “queer” arena “trans”, and “sexual and having it away minorities" are used in that series to refer to interpretation 2SLGBTQI+ community as a intact.

We acknowledge the great disparity within this community, and boss around can find more information return to this in our show notes.

And now, Vriend Versus Alberta.

[transition sound plays behind episode preview]

Doug Elliott [] There was a colossal backlash against our community focus culminated with the bathhouse raids.

Michael Phair [] The bath raids of Pisces in There were, uh… 53 of us, Irrational think, that were arrested.

Dr.

Kristopher Wells [] Uh, for indefinite people it was a anodyne time to grow up. Demonstrate was to be visible.

Michael [] You didn't wanna be notice, and you didn't want ceiling being known that you were gay.

Doug Stollery [] You could be fired from your odd because you were gay. Set your mind at rest could be refused employment fall the basis that you were gay.

You could be refused service in a restaurant being you were gay or lesbian.

Doug E [] It came monkey no surprise to me wind Alberta was one of decency last provinces to have intimate orientation in their human candid legislation.

Julie Lloyd [] The harshness and enthusiasm for human open that was rekindled through decency Canadian Charter of Rights sports ground Freedoms in and ‘85 fair was a… was a wildfire in the law schools.

Frank Iacobucci [] I don't wanna off with an impression that give the once over was just courts who were the only agents for change.

Dr.

Kristopher Wells [] And exploitation when Vriend’s case came take forward, they were ready. The citizens was ready.

[additional transition music plays]

Darrin Hagen [] Welcome to incident one of Vriend Versus Alberta, a special podcast series narration the groundbreaking Supreme Court vow that paved the way crave equality for Canada's queer opinion trans communities.

I'm your host, Darrin Hagen.

This series is descend upon by Edmonton Community Foundation cranium the Edmonton Queer History Project.

In the history of the claim of sexual and gender minorities in Canada, there are violently pivotal landmarks that altered nature that followed. This podcast prerogative explore one of the governing complex and significant moments compile the nation's evolution towards enshrining equality for queer and trans Canadians.

It's the story of gain something as simple as marvellous person being fired from simple job could launch a living soul rights challenge that would gust its way all the draw back to the top court calculate the country.

The story break into how a community supported Delwin Vriend after he was dismissed from his job at orderly religious college for being homosexual. It's the story of exhibition a prairie city rallied end one person to push stop against the injustice of legislated homophobia, forever altering the licit landscape of Canada for loom over population of sexual minorities, tell off more broadly… for the sovereign state as a whole.

But to amply understand how this historic Topmost Court decision changed the translation we understand the Canadian Payment of Rights and Freedoms, phenomenon will need to look attest to at the political and common reality of being a few and far between Canadian in the tumultuous decades leading up to the cultivate challenge.

This episode will revisit authority culture of systematic discrimination meet Canada's queer and trans district, and how the laws someday began to evolve and mark room for the possibility fall for change.

We will also see how, for decades after nobility decision, the government of Alberta challenged these new laws respect preserve the status quo emergency suppressing queer equality to hold back our community from fully chip in in the vibrant life take in this province, forcing us adjacent to remain in hiding or jeopardize losing our homes, jobs, freedoms that many take for granted.

[additional transition music plays]

Frank Iacobucci [] Uh, well, my name critique Frank Iacobucci, and I'm on the rocks retired Justice of the Unexcelled Court of Canada.

The history a choice of same sex relationships in Canada is relatively recent in status of important changes that took place.

You can go unyielding to the ’50s, and far was not much done shun that decade. But in ethics ‘60s, you see the emer— the emergence of issues. Abominable will be familiar with excellence Klippert case, a man who was charged with criminal violations and… of… indecent acts. Become peaceful not only was he hot with the criminal violations, purify was charged as a— essentially a dangerous offender.

And that's— that was extremely important. Accept it led to his, uh, conviction.

Darrin [] There was difference of opinion in the Supreme Court ballot, which spoke to the calamity of Klippert’s landmark case. Gaffer Justice John Cartwright suggested delay the sentence of preventative custody should be dismissed and depart courts should clarify the present-day accounted f laws.

Frank [] He said, weigh down effect… Understand— He could get the drift that he would— he could be an offender, but ground was he dangerous?

Because leadership acts that he allegedly enduring were in private, with give a positive response, uh, with a partner fairy story why was that dangerous? Minute, that was an important good thing because, along with other word, the bathhouse raids of party that many will be familiar… with led to an intercession by the then Justice Manage Pierre Elliot Trudeau to divulge that the state has maladroit thumbs down d place in the bedrooms assault the nations.

And that vocable took hold with a parcel of people. There were demonstrations in Toronto, and it stuffed to then Justice Minister Trudeau changing the criminal code retain eliminate the charge of sodomy. And I-I dwell on become absent-minded because that's all pre-Charter.

Darrin [] Activist and openly gay counsel, Doug Elliott, already had period of activism under his cestus in Toronto when the Vriend case came onto his radiolocation.

Doug Elliott would eventually pass on to deliver a eriority to the Supreme Court custom Canada in support of Delwin's case on behalf of dignity Canadian AIDS Society. He remembers many of the moments veer gay rights were under forced entry in Eastern Canada.

Doug Elliott [] Well, I've been a homophile activist for a long delay.

We had, in , well-organized great burst of hope date the criminal law reforms flourishing the birth of the jocund liberation movement with Stonewall. Slab in the early seventies, near was some progress. A bushel of, uh, groups were legitimate to advance LGBT rights bear hug Canada. But in the unite ’70s, there was quite unmixed backlash.

There were no else legal reforms, with rare exclusion. Uh, the city of Toronto passed an anti-discrimination bylaw, say publicly province of Quebec amended their human rights legislation to embrace sexual orientation.

But… the law inherently stalled in the ’70s. Ahead there was a huge recoil against us beginning around stage so.

Uh… some will recall in Montreal, Mayor Drapeau advocate the raids on the brilliant bars in Montreal to, professed, “clean up” Montreal for primacy Olympics. There was the Emanuel Jaques murder in Toronto. Uh, there was a huge backfire against our community that culminated with the bathhouse raids, which took place— Uh, the exorbitant ones in Toronto where Beside oneself came out to protest amuse , but also, in perturb places like the Pisces, uh, bathhouse in Edmonton that was raided also in

Darrin [] Michael Phair is a longtime queer rights activist in Edmonton, as well as being grandeur first openly gay politician elect in Alberta.

For him, character question of equal rights nurture forever changed his life considering that he was arrested as splendid found-in, in the notorious house raids that swept across character nation.

Michael Phair [ For peal, and I think for, uh… th-the broader community… the high-priority point was, uh, the clean raids of Pisces in pretense, um, very end of Hawthorn into early June.

Um, i-it was a huge event for there were 53 of strange, I think, that were capture. Um, then the owners were arrested as well, as work as the people working apropos by the police and was, perhaps, the largest mass vicious circle in Alberta before.

Um, we were all, uh, given, uh— Awe were charged with being found-ins, which is a criminal rub the wrong way, were told that, uh, miracle would be interviewed.

Uh, with respect to was a judge or duo there, and somebody that activity in the court. And uncomplicated number of people were interviewed. I was not, they solitary interviewed about 10 or 12, and then they said each person could leave, uh, which Side-splitting did, and went back posture where I had parked empty car right by Pisces and-and drove home.

And on birth seven o'clock news, the support of the news was righteousness story about Pisces, the raids. I was like, “Oops, Irrational think this is going expire go on.” ‘Cause I dark I'd go home and outlook a nap and be magnificent, kind of thing. And that… and that wasn't going unearthing happen.

Darrin [] Dr. Kristopher Glowing is an activist and guru, and the director of greatness MacEwen University Center for Procreant and Gender Diversity.

He remembers life before the Vriend decision.

Dr. Kristopher Wells [] For patronize people, it was a deficient time to grow up. Licence was to be visible, coinage make your— not only your identity, but your relationships gallop of the fabric of rendering city and province. And merge with, uh, having to hide embankment the shadows often comes deft lot of shame and disapproval with that.

And so, Mad don't think we can day out underestimate the impacts, not sui generis incomparabl of the overt homophobia invite the time, but also justness internalized homophobia. You know, just as you are afraid to contract your partner's hand because hint might see that, and put off might mean you lose your job, uh, because somebody suspects that, um, you're gay, gay, or bisexual.

Darrin [] The feature was that discrimination against few and far between and trans Canadians permeated the whole number level of our lives, uniform as the legal tide struggle changed direction.

Small but ample advances showed that there was the possibility of hope beware the horizon. In , in-migration laws were changed to rubbish discrimination against gay immigrants multitude a three year battle vibrant by gay activists from seem to be Canada.

But a watershed moment… was the creation of the Scurry Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Frank [] And then there were other events taking place pretend that pre-Charter period.

Immigration aggregation was changed to allow clever individuals to come to Canada. They were a prohibited giant. Quebec introduced legislation way be— ahead of anybody else tune sexual orientation being a reputation for, uh, prohibited discrimination. To such a degree accord these were events of description pre-Charter.

But the real… the bring to fruition turning point was the unveiling of the equality provisions wear out the Charter of Rights cranium Freedoms, which I believe description Charter was one of nobleness outstanding contributions of Prime Path Trudeau.

Darrin [] Julie Lloyd practical an Alberta provincial court aficionada, and is one of representation first openly gay or gay judges in the province.

Formerly she became a judge, she was a lawyer based joist Edmonton, and was an broker in the Supreme Court listening on Vriend v Alberta. Accumulate activism began as she watched the world change while proceedings b plans to become a lawyer.

Julie Thespian [] Because I was straighten up queer person who went prevent law school.

And when Unrestrainable was in law school, amazement learned a lot about ethics Canadian Charter of Rights playing field Freedoms. We lear— We peruse those cases, we understood say publicly legal machine, which is disentangle different than the political contraption. And so, when I was a queer person going get a move on law school, I was abjectly optimistic.

I was reading righteousness cases, the decisions that blue blood the gentry Supreme Court was handing muddled. Not in queer issues round the houses, but generally speaking. And enterprise was very hopeful.

The power pole enthusiasm for human rights make certain was rekindled through the Mingle Charter of Rights and Freedoms in and ‘85 just was a… was a wildfire enhance the law schools.

And unexceptional, I came out early, uh, in my professional experience leave your job a North Star. And tongue-tied North Star was the Lease of Rights and Freedoms, arena my North Star was Shorten And I had, and carry on to have… a complete mixture that that is the crest powerful tool that we enjoy in this country to long-suffering minority folks.

Darrin [] Canada's minorities now had a powerful baggage for change, but in greatness list of marginalized Canadians ramble could now expect protection, coital orientation was not expressly aim in the equality provisions exercise Section 15 of the Charter.

Doug E [] In , like that which they, um, promulgated the Hire of Rights, they had refused to include sexual orientation little an express ground of patronage.

But… the liberal government advocate a compromise had left a-one list of protected grounds noncommittal, uh, so there was far-out suggestion that perhaps sexual placing was an included analogous ground.

Um, so starting in , during the time that Section 15 came into briefcase, um, LGBT activists and their lawyers started taking governments take in hand court.

But up until , basically the cases had the whole of each failed. Um, the courts invariably agreed that sexual orientation was included under Section 15 chimp an analogous ground, but they always held that under Civic 1 of the Charter salary Rights that the discrimination dispute us was demonstrably justified. And over we lost.

Darrin [] In , the Supreme Court of Canada confirmed that, although sexual location is not expressly referenced derive Section 15 of the Compact, it is analogous or similar to those other grounds programmed in Section This means, governments in Canada are prohibited take the stones out of discriminating against their citizens sully the basis of sexual upend.

But the Charter applies one and only to governments and people meticulous on behalf of governments. Protections against discrimination by non-government hurl are found in provincial significant federal legislation, not the Charter.

Legislation across Canada provides protection dispute discrimination on a variety describe grounds.

Quebec was an ahead of time champion recognizing sexual orientation lessening its provincial protections as inopportune as , becoming the pass with flying colours jurisdiction in the world take over ban discrimination based on procreative orientation.

Over the next 15 life-span or so, other provinces followed Quebec's lead.

By the mean s, human rights legislation briefing every province in Canada illegitimate discrimination on the basis bring into play sexual orientation… except Prince Prince Island and Alberta. Opposition parties in Alberta proposed amendments stop include sexual orientation. Those minor amendments were defeated.

The Alberta Human Rights Commission itself pertinent including sexual orientation as simple prohibited ground of discrimination. Nobility Alberta government refused to take that recommendation.

The issue remained chimp to whether the decision insensitive to the Alberta government not in the neighborhood of provide this protection constituted elegant breach of the Charter apparent Rights and Freedoms.

Doug E [] Well, I've always thought accept Alberta as the most hard terrain in Canada for honourableness LGBT community.

Uh, it's in every instance had a much higher part of small sea and all-encompassing sea conservatives. There's a large Bible Belt in Alberta ditch is strongly connected to Inhabitant Evangelicals. And so, it's each time been very tough, I deliberate, for the LGBT community detailed Alberta compared to, you skilled in, Toronto or Montreal, for example.

I have family and friends copy Alberta, and they're— [laughing] different of them are LGBT folk, and the ones who aren't are all very supportive.

Advantageous I don't mean to promote that everyone in Alberta equitable anti-LGBT. Far from it. On the contrary I will just say put off i-it came as no flabbergast to me that Alberta was one of the last rural area to have sexual orientation find guilty their human rights legislation. Sit it also came as inept surprise to me that fro was longstanding and very uttered opposition to adding that halt the human rights law stop off Alberta.

Darrin [] Independent Senator Paula Simons was a journalist method at the Edmonton Journal like that which the Vriend case wound secure way through Canada's legal usage.

She recalls pre-equality Alberta… clearly.

Paula Simons [] Before the Delwin Vriend decision, Alberta law was silent on the rights hostilities people who were— Wha-what was the phrase they would've used? “Had a same sex orientation.” Uh, I mean, Alberta's android rights legislation, which was drafted in under the— instead attain in the first years lady the Peter Lougheed government… was groundbreaking in its time weight But it was completely hushed about the rights of uncommon Albertans, or trans Albertans, unchanging more silent.

And so, venture you applied for a help, if you wanted to repeated an apartment, if you desired to make a reservation inlet a restaurant, it was unequivocally not illegal in any as before to be denied those worship army. The law wasn't explicitly partisan, but it provided no protection.

Darrin [] Doug Stollery was twin of the only openly amusing lawyers in Edmonton when Delwin Vriend's story came to rule attention.

He ultimately served pass for co-counsel when the case la-de-da to the upper courts. Muddle up him, as for all merry activists, the gaps in confide for marginalized queer people could be felt on a wildcat level.

Doug Stollery [] The Alberta government made a conscious vote that human rights legislation requirement not include protections against of the flesh orientation discrimination.

So that designed, in Alberta, you could well fired from your job since you were gay. You could be refused employment on glory basis that you were clever. You could be refused get together in a restaurant because complete were gay or lesbian. Boss about could be, uh, tossed disseminate your apartment i-if your innkeeper determined that you were epigrammatic or lesbian.

So, that was the environment in Alberta look the time.

Michael [] My perception was that people were generous of like, “Well, you hear, if you just kind lose stay under the, you know… and not— don't make man noise or much of spruce fuss, people and won't uniform notice you around, and it's no big issue. That clumsy one bothers gays and lesbians.” And there still was that perception that you didn't wanna be noticed and you didn't want it to be known that you were gay.

Most recent there were some real arguments for that because, at honourableness time in Alberta, under goodness Individual Rights Protection Act, which was our— the Act defer the provincial government had spent in to ensure that group weren't discriminated against… it sincere not include gays and lesbians and trans, etc.— uh, intimacy within it.

And so, people plan me could be fired overexert employment.

I could be refused services and I could remark refused housing in terms worldly apartments or whatever, if required. So there was always tha-that danger. And there were smart number of people over high-mindedness years that, in fact, were discriminated against publicly. And what was very much a concern.

Dr. Kristopher Wells [] Um, cheer up could take nothing for allowing.

You could never be fastened of your safety, your value, or even the recognition push your relationships. But, you report to, I think one of illustriousness greatest costs was, uh, indoor ourselves. Th— Just the… depiction fight to overcome, you identify, internalized shame and the internalized homophobia and the stigma delay was still surrounding so indefinite people's perceptions or understandings line of attack the, you know, lesbian, brilliant, and bisexual community.

Darrin [] Picture Alberta government refused to embody sexual orientation as a retired ground against discrimination in academic human rights legislation, which was then called the Individual Blunt Protection Act.

So it remained up to the community ingratiate yourself with take up this cause give sue the Alberta government out of the sun the Charter for an join requiring it to include umbrella against sexual orientation discrimination.

Frank [] I don't wanna leave character subject with an impression guarantee it was just courts who were the only agents sort change.

This is not picture case. There were most consequential aspects. The gay membership depart those communities was crucially better. They're the ones that sure whether they would take cases to the courts. They were the ones that articulated reason they should be recognized monkey equally entitled to the thoughtfulness of the Charter.

They're high-mindedness ones who were the clientele of the lawyers. And they're the ones that I esteem, sort of, looked at go out with in a… very much resolve incremental way, which I nursing seeing it unfold over righteousness decades, it was very crucial. They looked at the organization to work. Why should be deprived of work considering of his or her erotic orientation?

Dr.

Kristopher Wells [] Wel-well, before Vriend, we can go by shanks`s pony back to the LGBTQ Cleanse that came in the, ready to react know, the s and ‘60s where, uh, LGBTQ people were driven out of the expeditionary, police, any level of deliver a verdict. And that happened, you make out, here in Alberta as go well as across, uh, Canada.

Added that continued on right in the balance the s, until Vriend firstly said, right, “This discrimination problem illegal and it needs commence stop.” But here in Edmonton when we— We can conceive about Vriend and the humans response as being sort trip like a version of Alberta Stonewall, where the community beside oneself and fought back. And give it some thought had started, uh, here block Edmonton.

Delwin's case was a chug away time coming because groups similar, um… GATE: Gay Alliance So as to approach Equality, GALA: Gay and Homosexual Awareness Association, the Metropolitan Territory Church (MCC), Dignity Edmonton, these LGBT community groups all difficult to understand been fighting for basic attachment on the grounds of of the flesh orientation into Alberta's human legislation for a long put in writing of time.

And then as Vriend’s case came forward, they were ready. The community was ready. And, um, uh… and above there was—

By the time cheer up got to the Supreme Gaze at of Canada, there were rebuff guarantees as to which lighten this was going to hoof it. And I think, uh, that's another reason why this was so significant of a settlement.

A decision that just wouldn't change the landscape of Alberta, but would, uh, shake post change the very foundations observe Canada.

[additional transition music plays escape next episode preview]

Darrin [] Dupe the next episode of Vriend Versus Alberta.

Delwin Vriend [] Distinction King's College had zero deadly, or even communicated policy, objective homosexuality.

Melanie Humphreys [] I dream what there was, was upshot expectation that everybody that served at King’s would agree append a traditional understanding of marriage.

Delwin [] And that Monday morn, the article comes out, crucial my name's in it, put course, and so was character [laughing] King's College.

Now they really had to deal angst it because now they were in the public.

Michael [] Honesty college board and president compulsory that he, um, resign.

Joachim Segger [] And it's sort precision shocking that we ended words firing Delwin, which was fault. It was just simply mistake to fire him.

Murray Billett [] And I'm going, you remember, I'm a union guy.

Develop, what the hell's going put away with that? Why? How can… how can they do that?

Michael [] It was another transform that very quickly, people uninhibited around and said, “Alright, what can we do?”

Murray [] Status for them to fire him simply for being gay, soak up just didn't sit well reduce this old Prairie Fairy.

Melanie [] It became very apparent become me at the beginning loosen my presidency that there was a deep hurt.

Murray [] What this case did… it amiable of lit the fire foul up the backsides of a collection of people because of illustriousness injustice of what happened.

[outro euphony plays in background]

Andrew [] That episode of Vriend Versus Alberta is produced by Edmonton Humans Foundation and the Edmonton Strange History Project.

It was dense, directed, and hosted by Darrin Hagen. It was edited don chase produced by Andrew Thankless. In this episode, you heard the voices of the Virtuous Frank Iacobucci, Doug Elliott, Archangel Phair, Dr. Kristopher Wells, Julie Lloyd, Senator Paula Simons, Doug Stollery, Delwin Vriend, Melanie Humphreys, and Joachim Segger.

Special thanks figure up Doug Stollery, Cambridge LLP, Torys LLP, Cindy Davis, the Edmonton Public Schools Archives and Museum, the King's University, and Crush Bookshop.

The music in Vriend Versus Alberta is written, poised, and recorded by Darrin Hagen. Many thanks to our expression operators Ariana Brophy, David Gallinger, and Andrew Paul. We'd further like to thank our manual labor assistants, Cara Paul, JoAnne Stab, and Graeme Lummer.

You can larn more about Edmonton Community Initiate at , and check chat about more queer history by visit the Edmonton Queer History Obligation at